The credibility problem hiding in plain sight
NPS has a trust problem — not because the metric is broken, but because disclosure is unregulated. Any company can publish any number with any methodology (or none) and call it their Net Promoter Score. There is no GAAP for customer experience. No auditor insists on a minimum sample size. No regulator questions whether the respondents were actually customers.
This creates a market for lemons. Companies with genuinely excellent customer relationships — measured rigorously and reported honestly — sit in the same database as companies that surveyed their own LinkedIn followers after a product launch. The number looks the same. The credibility could not be more different.
The good news: doing it properly is not hard. It just requires three things most companies are reluctant to provide: transparency, consistency, and the courage to publish a number that might not be 95.